The Tipstrr Experiment: Can You Make Money Following Tipsters?

Can you actually make a consistent profit following professional betting tipsters? And more importantly, can you do it using betting exchanges without worrying about bookmaker restrictions?

That’s exactly what I’m going to find out.

I’ve selected five tipsters from Tipstrr, one of (if not the biggest) platform that tracks the performance of sports betting tipsters, and I’m going to follow their selections using real money.

Over the coming months, I’ll track every bet, record my profits and losses, and publish monthly updates showing exactly how each tipster performs.

There will be no cherry picking winning bets, no hiding losing months, and no unrealistic claims about guaranteed profits.

Just five tipsters, real bets, and transparent results.

Let’s see if following professional tipsters can actually make money.

Tipstrr Experiment

 Results After 2 Weeks

(Staking 1 point per selections)

Flat Staking

(Staking to win 1 point per selection)

Stake to win

Tipstrr Experiment – 2 Weeks 

MetricFlat StakingWin 1 Point
Total Bets9595
Net Profit+4.23 pts+9.5 pts
Total Staked 95 pts98.6 pts
ROI4.5%9.6%
Commission (2%)1.02 pts0.96 pts

Tipstrr Experiment Results

Tipsters at a glance (Click link for detailed stats)

NameHistorical ROISportCostLink
BetIKO11.5%Football£39Click Here
Javier Rey9.84%Football£79Click Here
Pointbypoint8.71%Tennis£39Click Here
Footydraws10110.45%Football£29Click Here
Vic7779.78%Football£39Click Here

Tipstrr Experiment – Early Results and Observations

It’s been a profitable start to the experiment, with 3 out of the 5 tipsters currently showing a profit! Of course, we’re dealing with a very small sample size, so it’s far too early to draw any meaningful conclusions.

One of my biggest concerns going into this experiment was whether I’d be able to get anywhere near the odds quoted by the tipsters. After all, a profitable tipster is of little use if the odds have already dropped significantly by the time you place your bet.

So far, though, the experience has been mixed, and some tipsters have been considerably easier to follow than others.

How Easy Has Each Tipster Been to Follow?

Javier Rey

This has been the most challenging tipster to follow so far. His selections seem to move the markets almost immediately, often to the point where the available odds are no longer attractive enough to justify placing the bet.

PointByPoint

The main issue here has been timing. Selections often arrive early in the morning UK time, making it difficult to catch them when they’re first released. This has resulted in some missed opportunities.

FootyDraws101

Probably the easiest tipster to follow so far. I’ve regularly been able to match the quoted odds and, on several occasions, actually secure better prices than those originally advised. A promising start from a practical point of view.

BETIKO

A slightly different challenge here. Some selections are in markets that aren’t always available on betting exchanges, which limits my options. I’ve also noticed that selections in smaller markets can cause the odds to move fairly quickly.

Vic777

Another tipster who has been relatively straightforward to follow. So far, getting bets placed at reasonable odds hasn’t been a major issue.

What Have I Learned So Far?

Unsurprisingly, I’ve missed a number of selections already. However, I went into this experiment fully expecting that I wouldn’t be able to back absolutely everything.

The important question isn’t necessarily whether I can follow every single tip, but whether I can make a profit from the selections I’m realistically able to back.

Once the first full month is complete, I’ll be taking a closer look at two important factors:

  • Missed selections: How many bets have I been unable to place, and what impact could this have on the overall results?
  • Odds comparison: How do the odds I’ve actually taken compare with those originally quoted by the tipsters?

This should give us a much clearer picture of whether the advertised results are realistically achievable for someone following these services.

Can You Profit Following Tipsters Using Betting Exchanges?

Ultimately, that’s what this entire experiment is designed to find out.

My aim is to establish whether it’s possible to make a consistent profit following established tipsters while placing bets primarily through betting exchanges, rather than relying on traditional bookmakers that may restrict winning accounts.

I may also need to incorporate Bet105 for certain selections, particularly where exchange liquidity is limited or the required markets aren’t available.

It’s still very early days, and a profitable start certainly doesn’t guarantee long-term success. But with four of the five tipsters currently in profit, there are some encouraging signs.

The real test will be whether these results hold up over hundreds of bets, particularly once missed selections, odds movements and exchange commission are taken into account.

 

What Is Tipstrr?

Tipstrr is a sports betting tipster platform where bettors can find and follow tipsters covering football, horse racing, tennis, basketball and other sports.

One of its biggest selling points is its detailed performance tracking.

Rather than simply advertising winning selections, tipsters have historical records that can be examined using statistics such as:

  • Total number of bets
  • Historical profit and loss
  • Return on investment (ROI)
  • Average betting odds
  • Winning percentage
  • Performance across different sports and betting markets

Vic 777 Stats

This gives prospective followers considerably more information than simply looking at a tipster’s recent winning streak.

However, there’s an important distinction between a tipster showing a historical profit and a follower actually being able to replicate those results.

That’s what makes this experiment interesting.

Why Am I Running This Experiment?

I’ve been involved in sports betting for over nine years, generating more than £220,000 in cumulative profits through methods including matched betting, arbitrage, value betting and betting exchanges.

Throughout that time, one of the biggest lessons I’ve learned is that finding profitable bets is only half the battle. Being able to place those bets consistently is equally important.

Many successful tipsters advertise selections at bookmakers that are known to restrict profitable customers.

That’s fine if you’re just starting out and have access to those accounts.

But what happens when those bookmakers have limited you?

Even if a tipster has an excellent historical record, their service becomes considerably less useful if you cannot obtain the advertised odds.

This is why I wanted to approach the experiment differently.

Rather than simply following tipsters at traditional bookmakers, I’m going to see whether their selections can be profitable when placed through betting exchanges. All of the tipsters that I’ve selected are profitable to Pinnacle odds. In theory I should be able to match or exceed the roi by using exchanges.

If successful, it could provide a more sustainable way of following professional tipsters over the long term.

Why Use Betting Exchanges?

Betting exchanges allow customers to bet against other bettors rather than directly against a traditional bookmaker.

Platforms such as Betfair Exchange, Smarkets and Matchbook operate differently from conventional bookmakers.

One of their biggest advantages is that consistently profitable bettors are generally not subjected to the same account restrictions that winning customers frequently encounter at traditional sportsbooks.

However, exchanges aren’t perfect.

There are several potential disadvantages:

1. Different odds

A tipster might recommend a selection at odds of 2.10, but the best available exchange price could be 2.04.

That difference might seem insignificant, but over hundreds or thousands of bets, consistently accepting worse odds can turn a profitable strategy into a losing one.

2. Liquidity

Some markets have very little money available, particularly lower-league football matches and niche betting markets.

This can make it difficult to place bets at the advertised odds.

3. Commission

Depending on the exchange and your account, commission charges may be charged on net winnings in a market.

This is another factor that needs to be included when calculating the true profitability of a tipster. The betstaken on the exchanges have to account for this

How I Selected My Five Tipsters

I didn’t want to simply pick the five tipsters with the highest advertised ROI.

When selecting my five tipsters, I considered several factors.

1. Historical performance

I looked for tipsters with positive historical returns and a reasonable number of recorded selections.

A profitable record doesn’t guarantee future success, but it provides a useful starting point.

2. Profitable to Pinnancle

One area I paid particular attention to was whether a tipster was profitable with Pinnacle. Alongside this I wanted to see a decent sample size of bets that would give an indication the proitability wasn’t down just to pure luck.

3. Exchange availability

This was particularly important.

I wanted tipsters whose selections could realistically be placed on betting exchanges.

There would be little point in choosing a profitable tipster whose selections were only available in obscure markets with almost no exchange liquidity.

Tipstrr Bets Placed

4. Long term sustainability

Finally, I wanted tipsters whose approaches appeared suitable for following over an extended period.

The objective isn’t to make a quick profit from a handful of bets.

I want to discover whether following professional tipsters could become another sustainable sports betting strategy.

The Five Tipsters I’m Following

After examining the available statistics, I’ve selected the following five tipsters for the experiment.

NameHistorical ROISportCostLink
BetIKO11.5%Football£39Click Here
Javier Rey9.84%Football£79Click Here
Pointbypoint8.71%Tennis£39Click Here
Footydraws10110.45%Football£29Click Here
Vic7779.78%Football£39Click Here

How I’ll Track My Results

Transparency is going to be one of the most important parts of this experiment.

Every bet I place will be recorded, including the actual odds obtained and the final result.

I’ll track:

  • Number of bets placed
  • Profit and loss
  • Return on investment
  • Average odds obtained
  • Performance of each individual tipster
  • Overall combined performance

I’ll also compare my results against the tipsters’ published performance wherever the data allows.

This should help answer an important question:

Even if a tipster is profitable on Tipstrr, can the average follower realistically achieve similar results using betting exchanges?

Final Thoughts: Can You Make Money Following Tipstrr Tipsters?

At this stage, I genuinely don’t know how the experiment will turn out.

I’ve selected five tipsters based on their historical performance, but there’s no guarantee they’ll continue producing profitable selections.

It’s also possible that some tipsters will remain profitable on paper while my own results suffer because of differences in odds, exchange liquidity or commission.

That’s precisely why I wanted to run this experiment.

Rather than relying on advertised statistics, I want to find out what actually happens when you follow these selections with real money.

I’ll be updating this article every month with my results, including the losing periods as well as the profitable ones.

Bookmark this page and follow the experiment to see whether five Tipstrr tipsters can deliver a genuine long term profit on the betting exchanges.

 

Leave a Comment

Are you human? Please solve:Captcha


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.